I'm a bit late to the party viz Enchanted, by Aletha Kontis. It's been out for a while, and has been reviewed lots. However, the thing with having Lists, as I do, is that there they are, needing to be added to, and Enchanted is a must-have on my Fairy Tale retelling list (and some day I'll review Grave Mercy for my Historical Fantasy list, and Silver Phoenix for my multicultural list....)
So.
There is Sunday, a girl whose family is just riddled with magic. She is the seventh daughter of Jack and Seven Woodcutter, coming last after Monday et al. Each sister, in accordance with the rhyme, is the embodiment of the qualities for the child born on that day (Monday's child is full of grace, Tuesday's child is fair of face, Wednesday's child, which is me, and I resent it, is full of woe, etc.). Sunday gets to be bonny and giving, blithe and gay...which seems to guarantee a pretty happy life.
Except that Sunday has grown up in the shadow of her sisters' magic, not mention the exploits of her brother, Jack--pretty much the Jack of all the Jack stories--and he ended up mysteriously dying (or so they think), and Sunday's mother is cold and un-nurturing, and Tuesday got shoes that danced her to death, and so it's not exactly all sunshine and flowers in Sunday's family.
So Sunday goes off by herself, to write stories in the woods. And she meets an enchanted frog, and they become dear friends...and then he's a prince, and there are balls, and Cinderella and Sleeping Beauty are referenced...
But the former frog, now Prince, has secrets he isn't telling Sunday (like the fact that he was her frog friend), and in fact he has secrets he can't remember himself (cause of enchantments) and MAGIC and FAIRYTALES just burst out all over the place, like the beans planted outside the Woodcutter family cottage.
Will the ex-frog Prince and Sunday find a happily ever after? Will Sunday's sisters have satisfactory fates (too late for poor Tuesday)? Just what is the family secret that is at the root of all this magic? And how many fairy tale elements does one book really need?
Well, in this case, as long as the reader is prepared to go with the flow, the exuberance of fairy tales works just fine. I confess I was bewildered at times, as were the main characters, but it was fun. (On a personal note, "full of woe" turns out to be an interesting fate, which pleased me).
Sunday was a fine character, perhaps because we get to meet her before all the goings on really get going. The ex-frog Prince never gets to be quite a real character, in large part because he's lost a chunk of his memory, and he himself doesn't seem all that certain about who he is (and did he really spend time on Thursday's pirate ship? That little vignette seemed to come out of no-where, and may well have been a dream). There were moments of unexpected depth, particular with regard to Sunday's mother, and the nature of family relationships, that helped balance the whirl of enchantments, making this more than a light divertissement of a read.
So all in all, I enjoyed it, and recommend it to anyone 12 and up wanting a magic-filled entertainment with lovely dress-making scenes (always an added bonus!)
(If you found my summary confusing, and I feel that it might be, but like I said, I wasn't entirely certain at the time just what was happening, and retrospect hasn't lent clarity to the view all that noticeably, feel free to go read Kate's over at The Book Aunt).
helpful note on age: this is one of those books labeled YA that middle grade girls will love. Like Brightly Woven, and The False Princess, and, um....all the other ones that I am not able to think of right now. Which is to say--there's love, but no sex.
I just got this one! I can't wait to read it because I adore fairytale retellings. Hopefully I won't be too confused.
ReplyDeleteI hope you like it!
DeleteThis was such a fun review to read! I feel like I've been swept up in the whirlwind of fairy tales and fun. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteThanks! I was wondering, as I was writing it, if I was writing it thus because of the style of the book...and now, having had that thought, it is probably going to lurk in my mind with every future review and I'll never be able to do it naturally again.
DeleteDress-making scenes? Must read (although the fairy tale mashup is not my favorite). Also, I have always thought I was Wednesday's child, too--but before leaving this comment, I double-checked, and lo! my mother was wrong. Tuesday.
ReplyDeleteyes, I was thinking of you when I typed that! After reading your comment, I went and double checked too...but my mother was right. Sob.
DeleteAs a Saturday child, I always felt I got the worst deal. At least being full of woe is romantically interesting. Potentially.
ReplyDeleteI agree, Enchanted does seem like a book that could work for both middle grade and YA kids. Thursday was totally my favorite of the sisters, being a pirate queen and all.
ReplyDeleteHow have I NOT heard of this book before? Must get on this one STAT. Oh, blast! Goodreads is down for maintenance as I am trying to look this up. *shakes fist at Goodreads* Hmm, Book Depository said it only pubbed on July 1, so I haven't heard of it yet because it's new. Good to know.
ReplyDeleteI am sure you're just thrilled to read about my play-by-play of trying to add this book to a list so I don't forget about it. haha I'll leave now.
I've never heard of this, and it sounds marvelous. I love the idea of fairy tales bursting out all over the place...
ReplyDelete