9/7/21
Legend of the Storm Sneezer, by Kristiana Sfirlea, for Timeslip Tuesday
9/5/21
This week's round-up of middle grade sci fi and fantasy from around the blogs (9/5/21)
The Last Fallen Star (Gifted Clans, Book 1) by Graci Kim, at Rapunzel Reads
Emma Mylrea (Curse of the Dearmad) at Mr Ripleys Enchanted Books
8/31/21
The Wild Way Home, by Sophie Kirtley, for Timeslip Tuesday
Charlie regularly adventures in the scrappy bit of woods near home; it's a far cry from the ancient forests of Ireland, but its landmarks are a huge part of their emotional geography. When Charlie's much anticipated little brother is born with a heart problem, and everything becomes too unknown and scary to cope with, Charlie runs into the woods....
But though the major landmarks are still there, the woods are not the same familiar place.
Then Charlie sees an injured boy face down in the stream, and sets to work rescuing him But the boy is confused, and can't remember what's happened to him. Communication is difficult; the boy, called Harby, speaks a strangely broken English, and can't understand much of what Charlie is saying. And so Charlie realizes that time has slipped backwards--these are the woods of early Neolithic Ireland, and Harby is a Stone Age boy.
As his memories begin to come back to him, Harby manages to communicate his desperation to find and save his little sister, and Charlie's thoughts circle around similar anxieties for the little baby in the hospital at home. The two kids work together to stay alive (there are wolves in the woods, and food must be worked for), and at last Harby is reunited with his sister and father, and Charlie finds the way back home, with a sturdier mindset about the little brother waiting there.
It is a vivid picture of prehistoric life, the friendship and trust that grows between the kids is convincing, and the mechanism of time travel (a deer tooth Charlie has picked up, which turns out to be Harby's most meaningful talisman) is satisfactory. The mix of contemporary realism and the Stone Age past works really well, and there's enough adventure in the past to keep things moving nicely. What makes the book really sing though is how moving it is. I was so emotionally invested that I grew teary toward the end, and thought loving thoughts about my own family...(which I do regularly, but not always with such heightened emotion).
And now I look forward lots to reading the follow up story, The Way to Impossible Island, which features Harby's little sister and Charlie's little brother several years later....
(The story is told in the first person, and I read in someone else's review that Charlie is not identified specifically as boy or girl, which I hadn't noticed, and so I've avoided using pronouns here!)
8/29/21
This week's roundup of mg sci fi and fantasy from around the blogs (8/29/21)
Welcome to this last MG sci fi/fantasy round up of summer! (I know it is the end of summer because I am a Keen Observer of signs of seasonal change--my neighbor's "summertime fun" display, which included a giant inflated hotdog, mercifully with bun, has been replaced by "back to school" featuring an enormous inflated crayon, and other scholastic sundries....)
As always, please let me know if I missed your post!
The Reviews
Airman, by Eoin Colfer, at Say What?Stowaway, by John David Anderson, at Maria's Melange, Satisfaction for Insatiable Readers, and alibrarymama
Sugar and Spite, by Gail D. Villanueva, at Your Tita KateToo Bright to See by Kyle Lukoff, at proseandkahn
The Total Eclipse of Nestor Lopez, by Adrianna Cuevas, at The Book Search8/25/21
A Wilder Magic, by Juliana Brandt
Sybaline's family has lived in their Appalachian valley for generations. It's no ordinary valley, but one infused with magic that has become entwined with the family. They draw on the magic to help the course of nature along, working with it to grow and to heal. But their valley is doomed. The Tennessee Valley Authority is building a hydroelectric dam that will flood it, and they must move. This won't just destroy their homes and cemeteries and other beloved places, but will sunder them from the magic...
And so Sybaline says no.
Drawing on magic to work against the course of nature has consequences; serious ones, that ended up turning her grandfather into a tree, for instance. But Sybaline is blinded by desperation, and so instead of leaving, she goes down into the valley and raises a wall of water around it, creating a place where she and her cousin Nettle can live.
Things don't go as Sybaline expected. At first there is food and shelter, but as the water keeps rising, a design flaw emerges. Sybaline has magiced up not walls, but a dome...and when the water covers the dome, the two girls are plunged into the darkness one finds at the bottom of a deep lake. They are not in a sanctuary, but in a trap, and to make matters worse, three other kids got stuck inside too.
Stuck in the dark, with a limited food supply, water being pushed up by the outside pressure through the ground, and the cold becoming increasingly severe, it is clear that they must escape. But in order to break the magic, Sybaline and Nettle must draw on all the magic of the valley they can, even though there already signs that the magic is transforming them...
I am a huge fan of survival stories, and though "survival story" is perhaps not the main point of the book, it is still one that will appeal lots to fellow fans. All the elements I enjoy are here--the food foraging, the group figuring out how to work together, the growing anxiety and desperation...and the magical twist that has put the kids into this situation makes it especially interesting!
Thematically it is more than "survival story." It's a story of growing-up, of learning to be answerable to your powers, to face fears and uncertainties instead of running backwards to avoid them. It hurt to see Sybaline dealing with the lose of childhood security (made even more painful by her father being off in the war), but this hurt was soothed by her arrival at acceptance, and a reassurance that family was still family. It's also a story of living in balance with the natural world (complicated in this case by the natural world being magic).
I enjoyed Julian Brandt's debut, The Wolf of Cape Fen (my review), very much, and this one did not disappoint!
nb: A Wilder Magic is one of the many great elementary/middle grade specultative fiction eligible for the Cybils Awards this year; come join the Cybils team as an EMG Spec Fic panelist to read lots of them and try to pick which ones have the most kid appeal and literary merit combined in one package!
8/22/21
This week's round-up of middle grade fantasy and science fiction from around the blogs etc (8/22/21)
Escape From Aurora (Frostheart #2), by Jamie Littler, at Evelyn Reads
The Unexplainable Disappearance of Mars Patel, by Sheelah Chari, at Say What?
Warren the 13th and the All-Seeing Eye, by Tania Del Rio, illustrated by Will Staehle, at Silver Button Books
Well Witched, by Frances Hardinge, at Pages Unbound
When Days Tilt (Time Catchers #1), Karen Ginnane, at The Book MuseThe Wild Before, by Piers Torday, at Sifa Elizabeth Reads
Willodeen, by Katherine Applegate, at Beagles and BooksStephanie Burgis (The Raven Heir) and Amy Wilson (Lightning Falls) in conversation with The Reader Teacher (on You Tube)
Christyne Morrell (Kingdom of Secrets), at Literary Rambles (with giveaway)8/18/21
Five reasons why you might want to apply to be a Cybils judge in elementary/middle grade speculative fiction!
The call for this years Cybils Awards panelists has gone out, and anyone who reviews or talks about kids and ya books on line (blog, you tube, Goodreads, etc.) is welcome to apply to be part of the fun and excitement!
The Cybils Awards includes many different categories of books (ranging from picture books to YA fiction), and each category has it's own set of panelists. The first round panelists narrow all the nominated books down to a shortlist of 5-7 books, and then a second group had to pick the final winner. Anyone in the world can nominate a book in each category; some categories end up with lots of books and some with fewer (elementary/middle grade speculative fiction is around 110-130, on the higher end).
I'm the category chair for elementary/middle grade speculative fiction (roughly books for 8-12 year olds), and if you are reading my blog, this might well be the group of books that you enjoy the most too! I am always so happy to welcome new folks into the judging, and so to encourage you who haven't done it before, I offer--
Five reasons why you might want to apply to be a Cybils judge in elementary/middle grade speculative fiction!
2. It makes fall a lot more fun when you are a first round panelist. I love the excitement of the nomination period, the fun of marking books read in the spreadsheet, the wild placing of library holds and the arrival of review copies (mostly digital these days, but some still physical). I love having a forum in which I can honestly share with no holding back what I really think about books; it is very companionable.
3. You will find new authors to love, and you will become extremely knowledgeable about the middle grade spec. fic. books of the past year.
4. You will make new friends and quite possibly be inspired to review more.
5. As the category organizer, assembling the panels is part of my job, so this reason why you should apply is somewhat selfish. I want lots and lots of people to apply so that I can have new participants along with reliable veterans, and so that the panels can have lots of different view points represented. I take up one of the seven available slots in the first round because I'm the Lead Reader, but that still leaves six, and five more for the second round....
If you still have doubts, let me reassure you that it is less work than you might think!
There will probably be around 120 books nominated in EMG Spec Fic. This might seem like a lot of books to read, but remember, you'll probably have read a fair number of them already (if you haven't, you must not like MG spec fic, so you wouldn't be applying). Also each book only Has to be read by 2 panelists, and since I plan to read all the books, that takes pressure off of others. And also if it is clear to you before finishing a book that you could not support it being shortlisted, you don't have to finish it but can still mark it as read.
Though the nominating period ends October 15, you can start reading just as soon as you get the invitation email from me in mid September, giving you three and half months for reading (the shortlists must be assembled by the end of December). On the other hand, if you are having a baby, starting a new job, planning on spending the month of December snowbound with no internet access, or moving house this fall, the second round might be a better fit for you!
Things that I look for when gathering panelists:
Obviously, I really want people who know and love EMG Spec Fic; this is the most important thing to demonstrate when you apply! (Do not include a link to a review in which you say "I don't really like middle grade fiction, but I liked this book" or some such, which really has happened a few times in the past). I want a mix of parents, educators, librarians, and authors. I want a range of viewpoints; I'd love diverse panelists. . And I want panelists who are able to think clearly and critically about what makes for a good mg spec fic book and who are willing to enjoy sharing their opinions.
So here's the link to the application page on the Cybils website. Please apply! (you get to put three categories you're interested in, ranked...you could put EMG spec fic for all three if you wanted. Nb--picture books are the most popular first pick; graphic novels and High School non-fiction always would welcome more applicants. EMG spec fic is somewhere in the middle....
If you are on the fence about applying, please feel free to email me at charlotteslibrary at gmail.com with any questions or concerns.
8/15/21
This week's round-up of mg sci fi and fantasy from around the blogs (8/15/21)
Mission Multiverse, by Rebecca Caprara, at Ms. Yingling Reads
Jessica Vitalis (The Wolf's Curse) at MG Book Village
- The Scapegracers, Hannah Abigail Clarke (Erewhon)
- A Wizard’s Guide to Defensive Baking, T. Kingfisher (Argyll)
- Elatsoe, Darcie Little Badger (Levine Querido)
- A Deadly Education, Naomi Novik (Del Rey)
- The Tinderbox: Soldier of Indira, Lou Diamond Phillips (Aethon)
- A Peculiar Peril, Jeff VanderMeer (Farrar, Straus, Giroux)
8/8/21
on vacation this week...
....bookshopping in Ireland, so no round-up! I'll try to do one for next week.
8/3/21
Yesterday Is History, by Kosoko Jackson, for Timeslip Tuesday
Andre has come through cancer, with a new liver received from a young man who died in a car accident. He's ready to charge back into his life of academic success, complicated by all the school he missed. But along with the liver, he got something he couldn't have predicted-- a trip to his childhood home back in the 1960s. There he meets Michael, a guy a little older, friendly, cute, and insightful as heck. Andre has no clue how this has happened, until the family of the liver donor reaches out.
Turns out that young man was a time traveler, from a family of time travelers. And now Andre is one too. Blake, the younger son, didn't inherit the gene, but his parents assign him to teach Andre the rules of time travelling. This is a heck of complicated situation for Blake, for a variety of understandable personal reasons, and it's further complicated when he finds himself falling for Andre..
But Andre has been going back to the past to meet Michael again, and they fall in love. And even though he could imagine easily falling for Blake, what he shares with Michael can't just be dismissed.
Andre wants to make everything ok for Blake (hurting in the present) and for Michael (hurting in the past), but that's impossible, even with time travel. And after lots of internal struggle and another brush with death, he sets out to live his best life in the present.
So time travel is a mechanism for the romance plot, and that's fine, but it's a bit disappointing that except for one hop back to the Titanic, which we don't even get to experience through Andre's point of view, there's just trips back to see Michael (and it was really frustrating that Andre doesn't get Michael to promise always to use a condom, though mercifully we find that Michael doesn't die of AIDS).
Andre grows up a lot because of his experience in the past though, realizing that instead of just drifting along with parental expectations (in this case, medical school), it's better to find your own passion. Believably, he doesn't in fact find his (except romantically), but it's a good message for teens regardless.
It was really nice to read about a likeable gay boy supported by his family finding love! So read it for that, not because you like time travel, which exists here primarily in the service of romantic entanglement (that being said, the time travel did a good job making the entanglement interesting!)
8/1/21
This week's round-up of middle grade science fiction and fantasy from around the blogs (8/1/21)
Happy August to us all....
Here's what I found in my internet searching this week; please let me know if I missed your post.
The Reviews
15 Minutes, by Steve Young, at Charlotte's Library
The Beatryce Prophecy, by Kate DiCamillo, at Rosi HollinbeckBegone the Raggedy Witches, by Celine Kiernan, at Rajiv's Reviews
Bridge of Souls, by Victoria Schwab, at The Zen Leaf
The Broken Raven (Shadow Skye #2), by Joseph Elliott, at Log Cabin Library
Cogheart, by Peter Bunzl, at Rajiv's Reviews
The Crackledawn Dragon, by Abi Elphinstone, at Sifa Elizabeth Reads
Crowfall, by Vashti Hardy, at Library Girl and Book BoyDead Wednesday, by Jerry Spinelli, at Susan the Librarian
Edie and the Box of Flits, by Kate Wilkinson, at Book Craic
Homer on the Case, by Henry Cole, at Ms. Yingling Reads
Josephine Against the Sea, by Shakirah Bourne, at WOC Read
The Library of Ever and Rebel in the Library of Ever, by Zeno Alexander, at AMBFive Mg Fantasy books, at Beautifully Bookish Bethany (you-tube)
Authors and Interviews
Ben Gartner (People of the Sun) at MG Book Village
John David Anderson (Stowaway) at Fuse #8
Greg Van Eekhout (Weird Kid) at Whatever and Fuse #8
7/31/21
Ophie's Ghosts, by Justina Ireland
Ophie's Ghosts (May 2021 by Balzer + Bray) is Justina Ireland's first middle grade book, and it is a lovely immersive read, blending ghosts and a murder mystery with the daily life of a very real and relatable girl.
7/27/21
15 Minutes, by Steve Young, for Timeslip Tuesay
Casey Little is pretty ordinary, although his talent for being late is remarkable. He has a few friends, he is bullied at the normal level for his school (which is considerable), and he longs to be one of the admired, popular kids. But when, rummaging in the attic, he finds an old watch that used to belong to his grandfather, ordinary goes out the window.
The watch can take its wearer back in time, but only for 15 minutes. No one else realizes, so there's freedom to try again, this time getting it right.
This re-do ability is convenient for a kid, like Casey, who's a bit of a klutz and who embarrasses himself a lot. And by fixing all his mistakes he is, in fact, able to attract the attention of one of the popular girls and even excel at football (a game where it helps to know in advance which way everyone's going to go). But the watch has a mind of its own, and sometimes time goes back when the watch thinks it should, complicating things.
As Casey tries to achieve his (flawed) ideas of perfection, he drifts away from his old friends, and when he realizes that the worst of the bullies, the football star of the school, is in fact the victim of bullying from his own father, he quits the cycle of do-overs, and finds peace in the present. It's a rather abrupt change of heart, but still a nice ending.
I myself don't have much patience for middle school kids who are thoughtless and self-centered, and so didn't like Casey at all for most of the book. There's a lot of humor that will appeal to Wimpy Kid fans, which means that it's not humor I find all that funny, and the number of times kids get their heads flushed by the bullies is ridiculous. So not a book for me.
But it is quick read, and an interesting premise, and the final point of the story is a valuable one (about compassion, not making judgements, and a touch of trying to be one's authentic self) and so I'm sure there are kids out there for whom it is the right book....7/25/21
Hi all! Here's what I found this week; let me know if I missed your post!
The Reviews
Dark Waters (Small Spaces #3), by Katherine Arden, at Ms. Yingling Reads7/24/21
Sisters of the Neversea, by Cynthia Leitich Smith
Wendy Darling and Lily Roberts are stepsisters, tremendously close to each other. Wendy's site of the family is white, from England, and Lily's is Muscogee Creek. They share a little brother, Michael, who they both adore. But Wendy's dad is moving back to New York city, taking Wendy with him, and the girls are terrified that their family won't survive.
Enter Peter Pan, looking for his shadow, accompanied by his fairy friend, Belle.
Peter plays Wendy and Michael like the expert manipulator he is, and they fly off with him to Neverland. Lily sees through him, but can't let her siblings go off with out her, so she follows after them on her own. When they reach Neverland, Wendy and Michael are taken in to the community of the Lost Boys, and Lily finds the other Native kids. Soon Wendy realizes that Peter Pan is a tyrannical braggart, and that Neverland, though it is a place of wonders and magic, is no place she wants to stay. Belle the fairy is herself having grave doubts about Peter, who, having defeated his pirate nemesis, is savagely killing the native fauna for sport and to show off.
But the Darling-Roberts family is up for the challenge of finding their way home again, and even Peter, in the end, finds a most unlikely family.
There's lots to like here, most notably the power of family. The bonds between the siblings not only held them together, but tied all the threads of adventure and magic into a moving story. And it sure was great to see the problematic issues of the original destroyed!
One aspect of the didn't work for me was the style in which it is written. There are frequent authorial intrusions, and some jarring ways of talking about the characters that threw me out of the story--at one point well into the book, for instance, Wendy is referred to as the "Darling girl." Additionally, there were many point of view shifts amongst the primary, secondary and even tertiary characters. Some were simply brief flashes, others lasted for longer chunks, and quite a few included back-story thoughts, and this made the story flow a little roughly for me. I don't like it when I'm constantly made aware that an outside person is telling the story; it makes the characters feel more like puppets than part of a reality I'm absorbed in (wondering, as I type this, if introverts are bothered more by intrusive narrators than extroverts?)
That being said, this is definitely worth a read! (Kirkus thinks so too, for what that's worth....and their review appreciated "the wry voice of the omniscient narrator."
7/20/21
No Ordinary Thing, by G.Z. Schmidt, for Timeslip Tuesday
As readers of my blog know, I'm a sucker for good middle grade time travel, and No Ordinary Thing, by G.Z. Schmidt, was a very nice one indeed!
When his parents died when he was very young, Adam went to live with his uncle. Life in the Biscuit Basket, his uncle's bakery, is (literally) sweet, but Adam is withdrawn (never talking at school unless he has to, and with no friends) and worried about his dying pet mouse. Business is very bad indeed, and the bakery's future looks grim.
Then a stranger arrives, and greets Adam as if they know each other, pulling out a lovely snow globe in which is the cityscape of Manhattan. He offers no explanations, just the enigmatic words "great things are in store for you" and "Tonight, go up to the attic." Adam does, and finds a snow globe of his own. But there is nothing in it other than a layer of snow.
This soon changes, and when the cityscape appears in it, Adam is transported back in time to a winter's day in New York of the 1930s. Other journeys await, falling within the years between the first journey and Adam's present of 1999, both within the city and to a smaller town some ways away. The people Adam meets are all connected to the time magic of the snow globe, and to two other talismans of time, one tied to the present, the other to the future...
Life for Adam is now full of mystery, danger from an enemy who wants the magic for his own greedy purposes, and snatched friendships in other times. And with his adventures in time, his desire to fix things, not just for himself but for those he meets, grows. But the gifts of time magic are tricky things....
So clearly I'm not going into lots of detail here. Suffice to say--good characters, good mystery to be unraveled, lots of difficult choices, interesting visits to the past, and an a satisfying (though somewhat rushed) ending. I especially liked Adam's connection to Victor, one of the homeless men in the nearby shelter where Adam takes unsold baked goods--Victor was once a mathematician, and I like his thoughts about time lots (Victor is also the hero of the final confrontation....). The time travel is interesting--Adam never stays very long in any place or time, and his visits to the same places are sometimes out of chronological order. I'm not quite sure why the snow globe took him when and where it did, but it all ties together (clever snow globe!).
If you love time travel stories that are centered on making meaningful connections across time, this is one you'll like lots!
note re diversity--Adam's mother was from China, and the author likewise was born in China but grew up in the US.
7/18/21
This week's round-up of middle grade fantasy and sci fi from around the blogs (7/18/21)
The Clockwork Crow, by Catherine Fisher, at Leaf's Reviews
Song of the Far Isles, by Nicholas Bowling, at Book-Bound
Warren the 13th and the All-Seeing Eye, by Tania del Rio, illustrated by Will Staehle, at Twirling Book Princess
Kerelyn Smith (Mulrox and the Malcognitos) at The Bookish Society (podcast)
Other Good Stuff
"10 Summer Fantasy Books for Middle Grade Readers" at alibrarymama7/17/21
Too Bright to See, by Kyle Lukoff
Bug's beloved Uncle Roderick has just died, at the much too young age of thirty-two. He moved to the old (quite possibly haunted) family house in rural Vermont to live with Bug's mom when her husband died and Bug was just a little baby, giving up his own life in New York as a drag queen, and he was incredibly dear to both of them. Now it's just the two of them, and Bug's mom card designing work isn't bringing enough in to cover all the medical bills...
On top of that sadness and worry, Bug's best/only real friend, Moira, is leaping toward middle school and wants to bring Bug with her into a world of clothes and make-up and growing up. Bug sees Moira is on her way to becoming a woman, but feels unable to enthusiastically follow that path, feeling more like a shadow, or a doll, or someone just going through the motions. Bug is in the habit of narrating life as a servant girl, or a princess, or other flights of imagination, trying on different types of girl-ness, but nothing seems right.
"Trying to picture myself as a teenage girl is like staring at the sun, too bright to see, and it hurts."
Bug's house is undeniably spooky, with cold spots and strange noises, and reflections in the mirror that look like strangers. But this summer more active hauntings begin (poltergeist-ness, Ouija board strangeness, creepy dreams, and strange voices), building up to the undeniable fact that Uncle Roderick still cares about Bug, and is trying to communicate something awfully important.
Bug isn't a girl, but a boy.
And when he realizes that, everything falls into place in his mind. His mom is supportive, Moira, and even the other girls in Moira's circle of friends, are cool with it, and the new middle-school also takes it comfortably in stride. It is a happy ending; even the card designing business picks up.
So the ghost part of the story makes this fantasy, and there is some creepy tension from the haunting, but it is mainly the story of a lonely, sad kid experiencing gender-dysphoria, and then relief from realizing what he is feeling, and finaly the peace that comes when he can act on those feelings. It's a really moving story, and I so appreciated that Bug's realization that he is a boy wasn't a traumatic disaster. For kids who are themselves trans, it will, I think, be a great comfort have Bug's story in their minds, and for kids who aren't trans, but ready to be allies, it will help them understand gender dysphoria and be supportive of their friends.
If you are thinking this sounds not wildly relatable, stop! We all go through the process of adolescence, figuring out who the heck we are, perhaps with others around us seeming to be racing along the path to growing up, and our bodies becoming strange, and the face in the mirror changing. Like Bug, I myself still try to make sense of my life through third-person narration...and still feel I'm acting a part when I wear fancy clothes and makeup (which isn't often). Though of course for Bug, and other trans kids, this is all at a different level of magnitude.
In any event, I liked it lots, cared about the characters, enjoyed the sensory experience of reading it, and think it's an important and moving book!
If you want a second opinion, here's a glowing review from Fuse #8. Betsy and I don't always overlap in our opinions, but this time we do!
*(just checked--there are now 9 copies, with two more being processed, in RI; 8 are checked out).
7/13/21
The Dog Who Saved the World, by Ross Welford, for Timeslip Tuesday
Georgie loves her dog Mr. Mash fiercely (he's a rambunctious, loving, and unfortunately gassy dog), but her father's new girlfriend, Jessica, is allergic. Mr. Mash must go back to St. Woof's dog shelter. Georgie immediately starts spending most of her free time there, taking him out for romps along with her best friend Ramzy. On one such outing, Mr. Woof runs off with an old woman's bathing cap, destroying it.
This is Mr. Woof's first contribution toward saving the world, because as restitution the two kids are roped into helping at her impressive, and very private, lab, home to an incredible virtual reality set up. Georgie is the first guinea pig to try it, and it's certainly impressive. The virtual reality is more real than even its inventor planned (there is a giant scorpion that crept in unasked for, whose sting is real....).
Then a terrible dieses shows up in dogs, and begins spreading to people. Mr. Woof, and all canine kind in England, are slated to be killed in an effort to control it. Jessica is among the scientists working desperately to find the cure...but it is not happening quickly enough.
The virtual reality set up is so good, though, that it can be programed to take its users to the future. And this is how Georgie and Ramzy plan to save the world. Without Mr. Woof, though, it wouldn't have worked....
There's a lot more to the book--crazy shenanigans are required, for instance, and plottings and planning, along with Georgie's more ordinary concerns about Jessica becoming part of her life, and Ramzy's worries about his own family (they are barely getting by). And all of it makes for a fun read, and it is really easy to cheer the two kids on, except, of course, that it hits rather close to home. (I really wish that it wasn't a girl from China who brought the disease to the UK. The author had no way of predicting the anti-Asian prejudice that happened in the US because of Covid, but it was in retrospect an unfortunate choice on his part).
In any event, the story is a good mix of the serious and the exciting, and dog-lovers, in particular, will be deeply invested in story (spoiler--Mr. Woof survives, and the cure he helps bring back to the present saves many other dogs as well).
Time travel through virtual reality is a new one for me, and I liked that part more than I did Mr. Woof (I am a cat person). Though of course it's wildly improbable, it had enough internal logic (of a mad science sort) to it that the improbability didn't matter much to me. Georgie's actual time in the future was very brief, and rather awful, since it was a time line where the cure came a year later. But at least that future never ended up happening.
7/11/21
this week's round-up of middle grade fantasy and sci fi from around the blogs (7/11/21)
Da Vinci's Cat, by Catherine Gilbert Murdock, at books4yourkids
The Last Fallen Star (Gifted Clans #1), by Graci Kim, at Jill's Book Blog
Alysa Wishingrad (The Verdigris Pawn) at Kirby Larson
7/9/21
The Other Side of Luck, by Ginger Johnson
Julien has been raised outside the city, following in his father's footsteps as a gatherer of wild plants. Una has been raised in luxury at the city's heart, the daughter of its Magister. But after Una's mother died, her father ignored her, whereas Julien's father, though growing old and unwell, has raised him with tremendous love and care from the time he was a baby, when his own mother died.
Una's father has ordered a particular, very rare plant brought to him, one that Julian's father has the best chance of finding; this would mean relief from poverty, and a chance for his health to recover. When a jealous rival has him arrested for floral malfeasance involving a misidentified poisonous plant, Julien sets out to try to save him from jail. At the same time, Una meets her mother's brother, who she never knew existed, and decides she'd rather live with her mother's far-away family than stay in her father's city, where she feels unwanted.
The paths of the two children cross out in the hills away from the city, and together they try to find the plant. Julien wants it to help his father, and Una wants it because she's been told it was her mother's favorite. Maybe, if she can smell its scent, it will refresh her memories of her mother....
But Una's uncle isn't what he seems, and bandits, treacherous terrain, and the unscrupulous rival complicate their quest. When they do succeed, the ending isn't at all what they expected....
I will now try to define what I felt was fairytale-ish about this story, in list form because that's what I'm in the mood for.
-- There's a dream-like quality to their quest. It's not our world, but somewhere far away and with different plants, and with a smidge of background magic.
-- The two kids each have a gift that crosses the line into magic. Julian can hear plants, and tells them apart by the way they sound. Una has a sense of smell that is likewise more acute than possible. Their gifts help them on their quest.
-- Another help comes from an old lady, such as is often found in fairy tales, selling "the soup of life" to the people of the city. Though at first it seemed like just really good soup, it actually is magical.
--and finally, the way the story unfolded, with two kids in distress setting off away from home to find the rare and precious thing that could help them, keeping going despite the dangers, is obviously fairy tale.
Where it departs from fairytale-ness is in the sadness of the two kids; a real, deep, aching grief that gives the book lots of heart, without weighing down the reader overmuch.
So I enjoyed the reading of this; I was on a train, and it was a good train book, I think (airplanes call for gripping excitement, which has to be really gripping to distract from the trapped, horrible tedium of a long flight, but trains, swishing down their tracks outside reality in a gentler way than airplanes, and with opportunities to walk restlessly up and down when the mood strikes, are more amenable to milder sorts of stories). It's not one I quite loved, though; mainly because I wasn't entirely convinced by the set-up and the ending. The ending especially felt unearned and not like the ending to the journey the kids had been on.
But in any event, the writing is lovely! It's a good one for a dreamy 9 or 10 year old reader (if the cover appeals, the book will too), and, for me, at least, it was a refreshing palate cleanser (which feels like a not nice thing to call a book, but I mean it kindly).
disclaimer: review copy received from the publisher