The Rabbit's Gift by Jessica Vitalis

I don't have a time travel book to review this Tuesday, but that means I get to say happy book birthday to The Rabbit's Gift by Jessica Vitalis (October 2022, Greenwillow Books)!  It has a very strange premise, based on the French story of babies being found in cabbages, with a twist of the baby cabbages then being delivered by rabbits, but the author manages to make this work in an engrossing, charming story!

Qunicy is a young rabbit, living in a magically hidden community that tends the fields where the magical baby-making cabbages grow.  He longs to be able to prove himself as a worthy rabbit, but he's small, and no-one seems to take him seriously.  Humans exchange purple carrots for the baby cabbages, and when Quincy sees the supply of carrots is dwindling, and the rabbits going hungry, he decides to set out into the human world to bring back carrot seeds so they can grow their own.  Forbidden, but worth it, if it works...

Only it doesn't work.  Quincy is discovered by a human girl, Fleurine, who follows him back through the tunnels to the warren, and who snags a baby cabbage to take home with her.  Pressured by her mother, the Grand Lumière of their country, to start behaving like a suitable heir, she longs for a little sister to take some of the pressure off her.  All Fleurine wants is to study science, and work with plants (there are lots of good science details!)

And now Quincy has to try to get the stolen baby cabbage back to the warren, before it dies, and both of them have to work together to re-build the relationship between people and rabbits, so that both can thrive.

Told in the alternating perspectives of girl and rabbit, this is a rich immersive story that gave me two lovely evenings of reading pleasure!  

Part of this was the writing-- I love books that make clear pictures in my mind, and this delivered beautifully without me being conscious of the specific descriptive words I was reading.  Part of it was the characters--Fleurine, who has a lot to learn about the responsibilities of her privilege and the lives of those without wealth and power, and who has a keen scientific mind that she's not being allowed to use, and Quincy, so well-intentioned and so determined...The way their paths cross and they go from antagonists to allies, working together to fix the mess the two of them caused, and bigger societal problems as well, made for a thought-provoking, well-paced story.

Short answer--yes, it sounds like a very odd book, and it is, but it is also not odd at all in its familiar middle grade themes of growing-up, figuring out who you are, and figuring out what you can do to make things better.

disclaimer: review copy received from the author.

This week's round-up of middle grade sci fi and fantasy from around the blogs etc (10/23/22)

Not much from me this week; it was Parent's Weekend at college (Bard, in the Hudson River Valley), so I got beautiful scenery and delicious apples (and time with my dear child) instead of reading:

But happily there are lots of other posts to share!  Let me know if I missed yours.

The Reviews

Always, Clementine, by Carlie Sorosiak, at Rosi Hollinbeck

The Brothers Flick: The Impossible Doors, by Ryan Haddock and Nick Wyche, at The Bookwyrm's Den

The Chestnut Roaster, by Eve McDonnell, at Scope for Imagination

The Dragon in the Bookshop by Ewa Jozefkowicz, at Hidden In Pages (audiobook review)

A Dragon Used to Live Here, by Annette LeBlanc Cate, at Semicolon

The Frost Fair, by Natasha Hastings, at Sifa Elizabeth Reads

The Ghost of Spruce Point, by Nancy Tandon, at Ms. Yingling Reads

Homebound, by John David Anderson, at  Say What?: 

The Mummy’s Curse (The Butterfly Club #2), by M.A. Bennett, at Scope for Imagination

Osmo Unknown and the Eightpenny Woods, by Catherynne M. Valente, at Puss Reboots

Outside Nowhere, by Adam Borba, at Ms. Yingling Reads

A Pinch of Magic, by Michelle Harrison, at Valinora Troy

The Rabbit's Gift, by Jessica Vitalis, at Middle Grade Minded

Seekers of the Fox (Thieves of Shadow #2), by Kevin Sands, at Cracking the Cover

She's Still Here, by Caitlin Alexander, at Bookworm for Kids

Skunk and Badger, by Amy Timberlake (series review), at The Children's Book Review

The Story of Green River, by Holly Webb, at Scope for Imagination

Tall Tales by James Riley (Once Upon Another Time #2), at Carstairs Considers

Theo Tan and the Spirit Fox by Jesse Q. Sutanto, at Book Dragon

Unmasked (Fright Watch #3), by Lorien Lawrence, at Barb Hopkins

The Vanishing of Aveline Jones, by Phil Hickes & Keith Robinson, at Scope for Imagination

The Verdigris Pawn, by Alysa Wishingrad, at Valinora Troy

What Lives in the Woods, by Lindsay Currie, at Fantasy Literature

Windswept, by Margi Preus, at Sonderbooks

Winnie Zeng Unleashes a Legend [Winnie Zeng, Book 1] by Katie Zhao, at Book Dragon

You Only Live Once, David Bravo, by Mark Oshiro, at Charlotte's Library

Authors and Interviews

Katherine Applegate (Odder), at The Children's Book Review

Katherine Arden (Small Spaces et seq.), at Fuse #8

 Nisi Shawl (Speculation), at WNDB

Adam Borba (Outside Nowhere) at Nine Bookish Lives

Ellen Potter (Hither & Nigh), at Writers Digest

Amy Herrick (The Tiltersmith), at Always in the Middle

Other Good Stuff

At Heavy Medal--"Mock Newbery Fantasy Contenders: Mapmaker, Ogress and Windswept"  I myself don't think Windswept and Ogress have quite what it takes, but have no other fantasy in mind I think might make it....

You Only Live Once, David Bravo, by Mark Oshiro

I really loved The Insiders, Mark Oshiro's 2021 queer, magical, middle school story (my review).  So I was very happy when You Only Live Once, David Bravo (September 2022, HarperCollins), got nominated for the Cybils and was a time slip book--reading it was three birds (1 pleasure, 2 happy duty), with  two curled up sit-downs.  It is also a queer, magical, middle school story, but with time travel!

David Bravo and his best friend, Antoine, are starting middle school together.  But they are on different schedule tracks, and 15 minutes of lunch together, plus cross country practice, is all they get.   His first assignment also discourages him greatly--a presentation about family culture and heritage is fraught when you are adopted, and complicated when you are Latinx, your dad is Mexican Brazilian American, and your mom Japanese American.  And he feels he really messed it up.  But worst of all he causes Antoine to have an accident that keeps him from running.  Antoine's father is set on making him a world class runner, and now David has derailed this, and maybe ruined their friendship.

So all he wants to do is just lie on the floor at home forever, wishing he could restart middle school. 

His wish is granted, in the shape of an annoying talking dog who says she's been sent by the powers that be to help him undo whatever mis-step it was that wrecked everything.  Fea (which means ugly in Spanish), sets right to work.  But each do-over just seems to make things worse.

Then it occurs to Fea that maybe it's not the past that needs fix, but the future that needs saving. Fea wasn't always an pushy time travel guide--she was once a young woman, back in the mid 20th century, who blew her own future.  She takes David back in time to see it  happen--the day Fea couldn't bring herself to say yes to the love of the girl who was her own best friend, and ended up with a broken heart.  And maybe if David realizes he'll only live once, it will give him the courage to acknowledge a truth--that Antoine too is more than just a friend.

There was a lot that awfully sweet here.  David's parents are just the best in so many ways.  Fea, who annoyed me lots at first, became someone to care about.  And David and Antoine are loveable (grown-up perspective), and relatable (mg school kid perspective)--both are figuring out who they are, in Antoine's case being honest with his dad about not actually wanting to be a world class runner, and in David's case, questioning his identity as an adopted child).  And of course figuring out what they feel for each other.

Since this is a time slip Tuesday post, I feel compelled to note that the time travel was very satisfactory and coherent, and was made even more enjoyable when Antoine got included.  I liked the trip back to the far past of the mid 20th century best, because it was such a nicely contrasting use of Fea's abilities (and also because it was a fresh scene, that added depth to the story).

The ending has a surprising and joyful twist as an added bonus (although I thought it was perhaps a bit too much of a good thing....like extra frosting)

This week's round-up of middle grade sci fi and fantasy from around the blogs 10/16/22

Good morning!  Here's what I found this week.  Please let me know if I missed your post.

The Reviews

Always Clementine by Carlie Sorosiak, at Scope for Imagination

Black Bird, Blue Road, by Sofiya Pasternack, at Charlotte's Library

The Black Slide, by J.W. Ocker, at  Say What?

Bridge of Souls (Cassidy Blake #3) by Victoria Schwab, at Lazy Day Literature

Calix and the Fire Demon, by Ron Walters, at Say What?

The Chestnut Roaster. by Eve McDonnell. at  Magic Fiction Since Potter

Children of the Quicksands, by Efua Traoré, at Charlotte's Library

Dungeon Academy: No Humans Allowed! by Madeleine Roux, at Twirling Book Princess

Gargantis, by Thomas Taylor, at  Leaf's Reviews 

The Ghost of Spruce Point, by Nancy Tandon, at Bookworm for Kids

The Girl in White, by Lindsay Currie, at Randomly Reading

Greenwitch, by Susan Cooper, at Entering the Enchanted Castle

Kiki Kallira Conquers a Curse [Kiki Kallira, Book 2], by Sangu Mandanna, at BookDragon

The Lords of Night, by J.C. Cervantes, at The Bookwyrm's Den and A Backwards Story

 Moongarden (Plotting the Stars #1). by Michelle Barry, at Say What?

Mwikali and the Forbidden Mask, by Shiko Nguru, at Ms. Yingling Reads

Pilar Ramirez and the ­Escape from Zafa [Pilar Ramirez, Book 1], by Julian Randall, at BookDragon

The Rat Queen by Pete Hautman,  at Teen Librarian Toolbox 

Thunderbird, Book 1, by Sonia Nimr, at Charlotte's Library

Where the Lost Ones Go, by Akemi Dawn Bowman, at Ms. Yingling Reads

Windswept, by Margi Preus, at Charlotte's Library

Two at Ms. Yingling Reads-- A Long Way From Home, by Laura Schaefer, and Nothing Interesting Ever Happens to Ethan Fairmont, by Nick Brooks

Two at alibrarymama-- Let the Monster Out, by Chad Lucas, and Secret of the Shadow Beasts, by Diane Magras

Authors and Interviews

Fleur Bradly (Daybreak on Raven Island) at Middle Grade Ninja

  T.A. Barron ar Fuse #8

R.L. Stine at The Yarn podcast

Ben Gartner (One Giant Leap), at MG Book Village

Jasmine Warga (A Rover's Story), at MG Book Village

Roslyn Muir (The Chimera's Apprentice) at Mr Ripley's Enchanted Books 

Children of the Quicksands, by Efua Traoré

Children of the Quicksands, by Efua Traoré (July 2022 by Chicken House in the US, June 2021 in the UK), is a very excellent mg fantasy set in Nigeria.  It was nominated for the Waterstones Children's Book Prize in the UK, and really deserves more attention here in the US.

13-year-old Simi is an overprotected city child; Lagos is all she knows.  So she's upended when her mother announces that because of an essential work trip, Simi will be sent to spend the summer with the grandmother she's never met in the remote village of Ajao. Her parents are divorced, and his father is too busy with his own work to look after her.  Simi does not relish the prospect of a summer without modern technology and creature comforts, but doesn't get a choice.

Her mother and grandmother are estranged, and her mother is very anxious that Simi not be exposed to her grandmother's stories and beliefs about the Yoruba gods and goddesses....but when Simi almost immediately follows a forbidden path into the forest, she finds herself exposed to this reality with a vengence.  A golden bird leads her into a lake of quicksand, and she is sucked down into a magical bubble world, home to other children who have been drawn into the quicksand.  Although she makes it out again, she's haunted by the experience.

Gradually she learns the story of the lake, and it's connection to the tragedy in her own family that was the reason her mother left for Lagos and never came back.  And she learns her grandmother is linked to the Goddess Oshun, who created the lake.  When the larger community, fed up with children being lost to the quicksands, decides to fill in the lake, Simi feels compelled to try to save the children trapped there....can she set things right in this bubble world, or will she become one of the lost children too?

That's the fantasy side of the story, and it was good--solid and compelling, believably resolved.  I appreciated that Simi is only able to set right the distortion of Oshun's original creation to what it was meant to be because of her grandmother's connection to the goddess--she doesn't have special powers of her own (unless bravery counts).

But what I liked even better than the fantasy plot was the real world adjustment of a city girl to a rural village.  She is a fish out of water, but her grandmother starts teaching her useful skills (like starting a fire, cooking, existing without running water), and gradually Simi starts to take part in the vibrant life of her grandmother's community, make friends, and feel at home. I really loved all the details and vivid descriptions that bring this part of Nigeria to life!  I would have been happy with just this story, but was even happier to  have it mixed with compelling fantasy.

Very highly recommended.  Also--not yet nominated for this years' Cybils Awards in Elementary/Middle Grade speculative fiction--today is the last day for public nominations and I sure hope it gets its nod!  Here's where you go to nominate--Cybils Awards Nomination Form and if you would like to browse a selection of other great books still waiting, here's a slew of them--EMG SpecFic Recommendations #Cybils2022 (padlet.com)  I can't nominate every book I love myself!

Black Bird, Blue Road, by Sofiya Pasternack

Black Bird, Blue Road, by Sofiya Pasternack (September 2022, Versify) is an emotionally fierce middle grade fantasy, set in the Khazar empire in Eastern Europe in the middle of the 10th century, a place where Judaism was the state religion. It's the story of a sister who would do anything to save her brother from death, no matter what the personal cost to herself.

Ziva and Pesah are inseparable twins. Even when Pesah is stricken with leprosy, and confined first to his room and then to his own small dwelling outside the main house, Ziva spends most of her time with him. She is the one who tends to his infected wounds (the first line of the story is "I have to cut off Pesah's finger today"). Pesah knows he is dying, and this is confirmed when he sees a vision of the Angel of Death. Ziva refuses to accept this. So when she finds out that her father is going to send Perah away to a leper colony, she harnesses up horses to a cart and escapes with him to set out for Byzantium to find a cure.

When robbers attack, all seems lost...except that with the robbers, bound to serve them, is a half-sheydem (demon) boy, Almas When at his urging Ziva breaks the charm that held him, he binds himself to her quest in return, agreeing to help her take Perah to the fabled city of Luz, where Death cannot enter.

Their journey really is a race against death, and they make it just in time. But is the promise of life that Luz offers one that Ziva and Pesah can live with?

Ziva is a formidably fierce character, whose single-minded determination blazes across the pages. In fact it blazes a bit too brightly, overshadowing Pesah and Almas. The scenes in which Ziva actually talks and listens to each of them are great, pushing her toward more self-knowledge and taking her out of her own headspace. But they are too few and far between.

Ziva is so very much the center of the story and so very, desperately, focused on saving her brother that she doesn't actually spend much time talking to him or to Almas, and so we as readers don't get to spend much time seeing anything from their point of view. This diminished my personal enjoyment of the book lots; though I sympathized with Ziva, she felt more than a bit one note to me. Pesah is shown to us through the lens of Ziva's thoughts about him, and doesn't get much page time to be his own person. Likewise half-demon Almas, literally dragged along in Ziva's wake by the binding between them, also with just enough time given to him on the page that we know he is an interesting person with his own tragic story. Ziva barely things about him at all though it is clear that there is going to be a romantic interest in their future, so we don't even get much of him second-hand,

But still the final conflict/resolution between Ziva and the Angel of Death was profoundly moving, and Pesah did get to make his final choice. The Angel turned out to be an interesting character in Its own right, which pleased me, adding depth to the final conclusion, in which Pesah, not Ziva, gets to choose the course of his own life.

It's not a fantasy for readers who like Adventure, but will appeal to those who like emotionally charged journeys through worlds rich in story, particularly those who are kicking against the injustice and pity of the world.

What I personally liked best--doing a deep dive into internet reading about the Khazars! I love it when middle-grade fantasy reading leaves me better educated!

I also appreciated that the fantasy in this story is rooted in Judaism, a very rare thing in mg sci fi/fantsy. This is one of three Jewish middle grade fantasy books that I know of eligible for this year's Cybils Awards. The others are Aviva vs the Dybbuk, by Mari Lowe, and The Two Wrong Halves of Ruby Taylor by Amanda Panitch.

None of these three have been nominated yet, so please consider adding Jewish representation to the list of Elementary/Middle Grade Speculative Fiction nominations! Cybils Awards Nomination Form.  And if you know of more, please comment!

Thunderbird Book 1, by Sonia Nimr, for Timeslip Tuesday

Thunderbird, Book 1, by Sonia Nimr, translated by M. Lynx Qualey (April 2022 by the Center for Middle Eastern Studies UT-Austin, originally published in 2017), is the first time travel book originally written in Arabic I've ever read, and also the only Palestinian time travel book I've read.  My only substantive complaint with the story is that it is just the first part of a longer whole, with a cliffhanger ending. I wanted more, immediately...

A personal complaint is that the sadness with which the story begins made it hard for me to get hooked..  Noor's beloved parents died when she was 11, and for the past two years she has lived in the home of her uncle.  His wife is shrewish, greedy, and unkind, but fortunately her grandmother is there to give her all possible love and comfort, and one night gives her an old  ring from her parents....and then she too dies.

Noor runs away to visit an old family friend, a professor of antiquities, to try to find out more about the ring.  The ring is tied to her parents research--they were convinced that the phoenix was a real bird.  And they were not wrong.  With its death and rebirth every 500 or so years, the phoenix maintained the boundary between the human world and the world of the djinn and other magical creatures.  It is time for the phoenix to die again, but this time it might not be resurrected....and the balance between the worlds would be shattered.

 And Noor finds herself, accompanied by one of the djinn (who are also worried about the boundary falling), undertaking a quest through time to recover four feathers from the phoenix's past immolations.

Arriving in 16th century Jerusalem, she meets a girl who looks just like her, who has the same ring.  The two join forces to find the phoenix, and escape after being brutally captured by soldiers to make it just in time to see the phoenix burn....and this first installment ends.

I have left out many of the lovely fascinating elements of the story that made it a pleasure to read.  Though there are a few uneven bits, like Noor getting a lesson in the Crusader history of the city from her new friend (interesting, but something of an info-dump), Noor was such a clearly drawn character that she carried me through the story without faltering.  It was fascinating to go back in time with her, and also to see Jerusalem through her terrified, Palestinian eyes.  And if I ever time travel, I would, like Noor, to have a djinn in cat form going with me to magically provide appropriate clothes!

I completely agree with the conclusion of the Kirkus review (which is how I found out about this one)--
"This richly descriptive novel paints a moving portrait of a lost, lonely girl; a historic land with a painful past and present; and an enchanting magical world. The cliffhanger ending will leave readers eager for more."

Book 2 comes out this November, and I will be buying it.

Thunderbird is eligible for this year's Elementary/Middle Grade Cybils Awards.  Two other Muslim fantasies that have also not yet been nominated are Nura and the Immortal Palace, by M.T. Khan, and Amira & Hamza: The Quest for the Ring of Power, by Samira Ahmed.  If you know of others, please let me know!  And please consider nominating one of these books (here's where you go to do that), to uplift middle grade Muslim fantasy!

Windswept, by Margi Preus

Windswept by Margi Preus, illustrated by Armando Veve (September 2022,  Harry N. Abrams) is a middle grade fairytale, in which a dauntless girl, with brave and gifted companions in true fairy tale style, must save her sisters from a curse.  It is also a fable of environmentalism, set in a time after the collapse of our current status quo.  And it is also a good read with beautiful writing, though not quite to my personal taste.

Tag's three older sisters went outside to play, and she tried to go to, but being younger, she was slower.  And so when the wind came up and swept the other girls away, Tag was left behind.  Shut up in a sad house with only a knot hole to peek through at the outside world, she was kept safe, like all children under 15, from being windswept.

But one day another child, breaking the rules about kids being outside, stuffs a message through her knot hole--a map showing a meeting spot.  And Tag remembers that there might be a way out of the confines of her safe house--up in the attic.  There is, and not only does she make it outside, but she takes with her a book of fairy tales that had been hidden up there.  The fairy tales, forbidden by the government, are as new and magical to her as the outside world.

She finds the meeting place, and there meets a group of other kids who are determined to find out where the wind has taken their own siblings.  The book of fairy tales is the only guide book they have.

Then comes a truly fairy tale journey, the sort where some will help and some would hurt, where wits and true heart matter more than strength. And in the end, as the reader of fairy tales knows she will, Tag frees her sisters and the other children the wind has taken.

If you have read fairy tales, you will recognize many elements of them in the story; it was like seeing old friends.  If you are a child who hasn't, it's no great mater--the magical journey stands on its own, full of encounters beautiful, whimsical, and dangerous.  This is the part that's not quite to my personal taste--magical episodic journeys just aren't my favorite thing.

That being said, I appreciate that there's plenty of emotional weight to this particular journey--Tag has (understandable) self-doubt, and all the kids (who I liked very much) bring with them the sadness of losing their siblings.  Heavier weight comes from the book's message about human greed and disregard for the environment, which though a bit forced at times was still powerful and timely.

My brain is such a word-eater when I get going reading that I didn't register the illustrations because they weren't words (oh, there was an illustrator? I thought when I started writing this post...sorry illustrators...)  But I see going back through the book that in fact there are decorations and some full pictures that help make this a Story, like Tag's beloved fairy tale book...

Short answer--glad I read it, parts were lovely and make memorable pictures in my mind that I appreciate lots, and I bet there will be plenty of kids who love it.  

ps.  I am currently frantically trying to read as many middle grade sci fi and fantasy books as possible, before the public nomination period for the Cybils Awards ends (October 15) so that I can my use my own nomination as best as possible, and also so that I can encourage others to nominate.  Windswept is eligible this year, but hasn't gotten its call yet, and there are a bunch of others still waiting here on the Elementary/Middle Grade speculative fiction ideas board.....If you've already nominated a book, thanks, and if you haven't, do think about showing a book some love! Here's where you nominate--Cybils Awards Nomination Form

This week's round-up of middle grade sci fi/fantasy from around the blogs etc (10/9/2022)

Welcome to this week's round-up!  Please let me know if I missed your post.

First, a reminder that everyone from around the world can nominate books for the Cybils Awards--it's  a great way to show love for a favorite book or favorite author, and a great way to bring attention to books that are sliding under the radar.  The public nomination period ends at midnight on October 15, and there are so many books that are still awaiting their chance, including some of the best middle grade speculative fiction of the year!  I'm the category chair, and I've gathered some here at the EMG Spec Fic Cybils Idea Board. and a * next to  a book in the round-up means it hasn't been nominated yet.  Here's the nomination form.  (eligible books are those published in the US or Canada between Oct 16 2021 and October 15 2022). Thanks for making me, the books, the authors, happy!

The Reviews

Abigail and the Great Gang Trap (Little Wade and Watch Tower #1) by Sean March, at J.R.'s Book Reviews

Alliana, Girl of Dragons, by Julie Abe, at  Jean Little Library

The Book of Wondrous Possibilities, by Deborah Abela, at The Book Muse

*Children of Stardust, by Edudzi Adodo, at YA Books Central

Empty Smiles (Small Spaces Quartet, Book 4) by Katherine Arden, at Hidden in Pages

*Ghostcloud, by Michael Mann, at YA Books Central

*Ghostlight, by Kenneth Oppel, at Pages Unbound

*How to Heal a Gryphon (Giada the Healer Novel, 1), by Meg Cannistra, at Cracking the Cover

Ida in the Middle, by Nora Lester Murad, at Islamic School Librarian

The Last Cuentista, by Donna Barba Higuera, at Susan Uhlig

*The Last Fallen Moon, by Graci Kim, at Children's Books Heal

Lodestar (Keeper of the Lost Cities), by Shannon Messenger, at Silver Button Books

*The Lords of Night, by J.C. Cervantes, at The Laughing Place

*Map of Flames, by Lisa McMann, at Geolibrarian

Marikit and the Ocean of Stars, by Caris Avendaño Cruz, at Your Tita Kate

*Monster Club, by Darren Aronofsky and Ari Handel, at Always in the Middle

*New Dragon City, by Mari Mancusi, at Ms. Yingling Reads, The Bookwyrm's Den, and Boys' Mom Reads

*Nothing Interesting Ever Happens to Ethan Fairmont. by Nick Brooks, at Always in the Middle

Odder, by Katherine Applegate, at Mom Read It

*A Rover's Story, by Jasmine Warga, at Cracking the Cover.com

*Shelterlings, by Sarah Beth Durst, at YA Book Nerd

The Tale of Truthwater Lake, by Emma Carroll, at Book Craic

*This Appearing House, by Ally Malinenko, at Charlotte's Library

Tommy and the Order of Cosmic Champions, by Anthony Gate and Anthony Rapino, at Say What?

The Twig Man, by Sana Rasoul, at Book Craic

*The Two Wrong Halves of Ruby Taylor by Amanda Panitch, at Jean Little Library

*The Vanquishers, by Kalynn Bayron, at The Story Sanctuary

Which Way to Anywhere, by Cressida Cowell, at Magic Fiction Since Potter

Witchstorm, by Tim Tilley, at Book Craic

The Worst Villain Ever, by Amy Bearce, at Say What?

Yesterday Crumb and the Storm in a Teacup, by Andy Sagar, at Twirling Book Princess

Two at alibrarymama -- *The Prince of Nowhere, by Rochelle Hassan, and *The Lock-Eater, by Zack Loran Clark

Two by Kris Humphrey at Log Cabin Library  Leo's Map of Monsters-- *The Armored Goretusk & *The Spit Fang Lizard 

Authors and Interviews

Kalynn Bayron (*The Vanquishers) at  Paola M Guerrero (YouTube)

Jasmine Warga, (*A Rover’s Story) at WNDB and YAYOMG

Sangu Mandanna (*Kiki Kallira Conquers a Curse) at Cynsations

Max Brallier (The Last Kids On Earth) at Middle Grade Ninja

Jessica Vitalis (The Rabbit's Gift) at Teen Librarian Toolbox

Michelle A. Barry (Moongarden) at Teen Librarian Toolbox

Alyssa Colman (The Tarnished Garden) at Withywindle

Ally Malinenko (*This Appearing House) at Bent Biblios Podcast  and  w-enternews

Emi Watanabe Cohen (*The Lost Ryu). at MG Book Village

Fleur Bradley (*Daybreak on Raven Island) at MG Book Village

Other Good Stuff

New Children's Book Picks October 2022 - UK Post, at Mr Ripley's Enchanted Books

Watch the trailer for My Father's Dragon at SLJ

This Appearing House, by Ally Malinenko

 

So today I found amongst the electronic detritus of my gmail a B. and N. gift card I hadn't used, went out to spend it, and after much thought and wandering came home with This Appearing House, by Ally Malinenko (August 2022 by Katherine Tegen Books).  And then I neglected household tasks and read it, so yay for me!

The House appears one day, at the end of a cul-de-sac.  Jac tries to accept without question that it is there, when it wasn't the week before.  

And what with the tensions already in her mind--the ordinary new kid in school sort, and the bigger trauma of her five year anniversary of cancer diagnosis, with a mom who's constant concern is becoming smothering. Every clumsiness, every nervous shaking of her hands, could be a sign that she isn't free and clear after all.

The House calls to her.  

Two of the boys who are class bullies dare Jac and her friend Hazel (a boy named after the rabbit, which the bullies have a field day with), to go inside.  All four end up going in. They find nightmare built on nightmare. 

Jac knows the House wants something from her...and until she figures out what that is, it won't let her go.

Was it pleasure reading?  Not exactly--horror isn't my thing, and the House is a horror-poloza.  It is a good mix of the profoundly disturbing, the terrifying, and the repulsive. I think young horror lovers will enjoy it. I have to admit I didn't linger on all the different nightmarish encounters, because my mind has a bad habit of playing disturbing images from horror books and movies back to me in exquisite detail which I don't appreciate.  (content warning--tooth trauma)

Before I could turn off the keen, alert, reading part of my mind, though, there was a tooth thing. If you, like me, knocked your front teeth out at a young age and subsequently had recurring nightmares where you bit into apples and saw your teeth imbedded in them, be warned!  This is the closest I can remember to feeling physically ill because of a scene in a book.

But behind the smoke-screen of the grotesque, this is a moving and thought-provoking story, about acknowledging trauma, but not letting that be all-defining.  Being angry, sad, and terrified about having gotten a crap deal, but being able to start letting life flow onward is good to think about. I rarely call books "heartfelt" because it seems a nebbishy thing to say, but in this case it feels valid-- Jac's story came from the author's heart and her personal experience, and it resonated with my heart and my personal experience (the teeth aren't my only past trauma--I had a bad patch of way too many MRIs myself.  Seven months pregnant, told I had a tumor behind my right eye, no way to know till baby was born if it was benign or not.....then baby and brain surgery simultaneously.  All better now, I hope, knock on wood....)

However, all that being said--short answer is that this is a good mix of horror, a really strong MG friendship (Hazel is great) and good and useful things to think about when one feels introspective.  

This Appearing House is eligible for this year's Cybils Awards in Elementary/Middle Grade Speculative Fiction, and is still waiting to be nominated!  If you would like to take care of that, here's the nomination page--Cybils Awards Nomination Form

The House in the Waves, by James Hamilton-Paterson, for Timeslip Tuesday

A vintage UK time travel book this Tuesday--The House in the Waves, by James Hamilton-Paterson (1970).  This is time-travel through medically administered drugs (a first in my timeslip reading) that send Martin, a mentally-ill boy, to a late 16th century fishing village near the old manor house in East Anglia where he has been institutionalized. 

Martin. taken from his abusive father when he was six, and been in foster care and institutions ever since, has withdrawn almost totally from reality. He requires assistance with eating and bathing, and makes no effort to interact with anyone. Only his imaginings of ancient oceans and the fossil shells now on dry land are real to him.

But then he finds a handmade balloon (not a party balloon, but handmade with parchment like stuff pieced together) stuck in a tree, with a note attached from a boy pleading to be rescued from imprisonment in a tower. Martin's attention is caught, and so he journeys illicitly from the institution to find and help the writer of the note.

And he finds himself in the 16th century, in a fishing village about to walloped by a tremendous storm. Following a few leads from the (suspicious, but preoccupied) villagers, he comes to the ancient and crumbling house of a mad alchemist. Locked up in a tower by the alchemist, his uncle, is Will, who has been sending out messages on balloons he has made from the skin of mice.... As the storm hits, the alchemist's house collapse, and Will and Martin barely escape.

It was very good time travel, with Will's desperate predicament vividly described, and  a beautifully creepy, yet moving, picture of the crazed alchemist uncle. It is a transformative experience for Martin, who cannot help but be engaged in the trauma of it all.

But then he wakes up in his own bed back in the institution, not having left it at all. It was a dream, a Freudian dream that has cleared his mind, and he is no longer detached from reality.

It was very gripping, and I read it in a single sitting, but there is much that made me uncomfortable re mental illness and children suffering from it. The detail and care with which the fat body of another child who seems to have a development delay was unpleasant, for example. And then there's the magical healing of mental illness being cured through drug-induced time travel and a few pointed remarks from the doctor pointing out elements of Martin's story that resonate with his real life.....not a very satisfying conclusion for the modern reader.

On the other hand, the theme of oceans, and drowned shells, and the fishing village and alchemist's house devastated by waves, makes the story strangely cohesive.  The alchemy part was fascinating.  And it was pleasing to see Martin come out of his isolation, and I did read it in one engrossed gulp. Well worth the $5 I spent on it.

This week's round-up of middle grade sci fi and fantasy from around the blogs (loosely defined to include instagram, podcasts, etc) 10/2/22

Good morning from Rhode Island. Here's what I found in my hunt for mg sci fi/fantasy reviews this week; please let me know if I missed your post.

but first--nominations for the Cybils Awards are open, and ANYONE from around the world can nominate books! (but authors and publishers--if you want your own book nominated, don't do it yourself just yet; you'll get a chance after the public nominations close October 15).  Eligible books are those published in the US or Canada October 16 2021-October 15 2022.

It would be possible to make a brilliant shortlist of seven books from what got nominated yesterday, the first day.  But there are so many wonderful elementary/middle grade speculative fiction books that NEED to be nominated!  I've put asterisks next to books in today's round-up that are eligible and still waiting for love. (feel free to let me know if I made a mistake!)

The Reviews

*Alliana, Girl of Dragons, by Julie Abe, at alibrarymama 

Amari and the Great Game by B.B. Alston, at Log Cabin Library and Kiss the Book

*Beneath the Sand (Unicorn Island #2), by Donna Galanti, at Children's Books Heal

*Charlie Hernández & the Golden Dooms, by Ryan Calejo, at Feed Your Fiction Addiction

*Eden's Everdark, by Karen Strong, at Charlotte's Library 

*The Fire Star, and The Wolf's Howl (Maven and Reeve, books 1 and 2), by A. L. Tait, at Charlotte's Library

The Girl, the Ghost and the Lost Name, by Reece Carter, at Book Craic and Library Girl and Book Boy

The Ghost of Midnight Lake, by Lucy Strange, at The Children's Book Review 

*Ghostcloud, by Michael Mann, at The Bookwyrm's Den 

*Haven: Small Cat’s Big Adventure, by Megan Wagner Lloyd, at Semicolon 

*It's The End Of The World And I'm In My Bathing Suit, by Justin A. Reynolds, at Original Content

Jack Zulu and the Waylander’s Key, by S.D. Smith and J.C. Smith, at Redeemed Reader

Leila and the Blue Fox, by Kiran Millwood Hargrave with Tom de Freston, at Sifa Elizabeth Reads 

*LightCasters, by Janelle McCurdy, at eviebookish

The Little Match Girl Strikes Back, by Emma Carroll, Illustrated by Lauren Child, at  Magic Fiction Since Potter

Minor Mage, by T. Kingfisher, at Hidden in Pages

The Ogress and the Orphans, by Kelly Barnhill, at fatin.rosnan

*Omega Morales and the Legend of La Lechuza, by Laekan Zea Kemp, at The Bookwyrm's Den and Unconventional Quirky Bibliophile

*The Patron Thief of Bread, by Lindsay Eagar, at Kiss the Book

Sky Song, by Abi Elphinstone, at Kiss the Book

The Spectaculars, by Jodie Garnish, at Book Craic and Mr Ripley's Enchanted Books

*The Supernatural Society, by Rex Ogle, at Kiss the Book

*The Vanquishers, by Kalynn Bayon, at Ms. Yingling Reads and The Story Sanctuary

*The Whispering Fog, by Landra Jennings, at Say What?

The Wintrish Girl, by Melanie La’Brooy, at  wendy_orr_author

A Wizard’s Guide to Defensive Baking, by T. Kingfisher, at Hidden in Pages

Authors and Interviews

Lois Lowry at The New Yorker

George Jreije (*Shad Hadid and the Alchemists of Alexandria) at MG Book Village

Katherine Applegate (*Odder) at The Yarn podcast

Lindsay Currie (*The Girl in White) at Teen Librarian Toolbox. and Novel on my mind

The Fire Star, and The Wolf's Howl (Maven and Reeve, books 1 and 2), by A. L. Tait

The Fire Star and The Wolf's Howl are the first two books of a new series by Australian author,  A. L. Tait (August 2022, Kane Miller in the US), and since I'd enjoyed others of her books, I was very pleased when they arrived in the mail..  And then I was very sad when I got to the end of book 2 and there was no book 3.  Here's an image of them from the author's website (and I totally agree with the Kirkus quote!)

Two young teens--Reeve, a new squire, and Maven, the companion/servant of a noble lady==are thrown together in a castle full of secrets. When a precious jewel goes missing, they both are desperate to solve the mystery; Reeve because his new lord has told him to find it, and he's desperate not to be dismissed, Maven because the jewel was to be her ticket to freedom.  Even though it takes a while for them to trust each other, and to learn each other's secrets, they make a great team (sparks fly, mutual respect grows), and it was delightful seeing all the intrigue and deception swirling around them through their eyes.

The Wolf's Howl sends them on a journey, accompanying Reeve's lord and Maven's lady (newly married) to demesne off in the cold and windy wilds.  There they find another mystery to solve, and once again I enjoyed them doing so lots!

I just hate it when I have a really solid book comparison to offer, and then I see the clever little marketers have beat me to it-- "39 Clues meets Ranger’s Apprentice in bestselling fantasy author A. L. Tait's new medieval adventure series. "  But then I read this in my own review of Tait's earlier duology, The Ataban Cipher--"Especially recommended to younger Ranger's Apprentice fans." I am the winner, and can now say how very much Ranger's Apprentice fans might enjoy this new series--likeable, smart main characters who are clearly the good guys being brave and having adventures and solving mysteries in an alternate medieval Europe-ish sort of place.  The Ranger's Apprentice books have better food and their main characters have better fighting skills than Reeve, but Tait's books take a deeper dive into the oppression of women in a patriarchal society.  And though I'm sad to reject the food, I'll take actively subverting the patriarchy. 

Dunno about the 39 Clues comp. though...seems a bit of a stretch to me, and my elation of just a moment ago changes to disappointment as I fail to think of a better comp of my own.  I can't think of any middle grade books that have illicitly educated girls solving mysteries in medieval court settings (but with no magic, dragons or ghosts). Surely more must exist?  I shall ask twitter.

In any event, The Wolf's Howl ends up setting the next book up beautifully, and I hope I get to read it sooner rather than later.

disclaimer: review copies received from the publisher

Eden's Everdark, by Karen Strong

Eden's Everdark, by Karen Strong (September 6th 2022,Simon & Schuster), is a creepy ghostly middle grade horror story; but that being said, it is also a story of love and grief, family and history.

Eden's mother never took her to visit Safina Island off the Georgia Coast, home to generations of her family who were first enslaved there and then made it their own place, where they owned land and became a strong community.  But after her mother dies, her father takes her to see her family there.  Not only does Eden find love from her kin in this beautiful island full of history, but discovers it's dark side, a darkness that was the reason her mother and grandmother left when her mother was still a girl.

Her mother left behind a sketchbook full of terrifying images--monsters, strange and spooky children, and more.  And Eden discovers these weren't drawn from imagination, but from real life.  When she finds a rift into the darkness, she feels strangely drawn to it, and goes through.  Just as the witch who rules this land of ever darkness, where the sun never shines, wanted.

The Everdark is a spectral overlay on the real world, and in the grand house built by the descendants of the plantation owners, the witch, who calls herself Mother Mary, exercises near total control of the ghosts she's captured.  Two ghost girls have been made her children, and she want's Eden to be her third dear daughter.  Eden is still alive, though...though possibly not for long....and she's determined to escape.  

But getting free means figuring out the sources of Mother Mary's power, and how to break it before she herself is broken.  And it means uncovering the secret of her mother's magic--the family gift of making things grow--and finding it with herself as well.

The warm and loving first section of the book is a sharp and very effective contrast to the horror of the Everdark, with its creeping rot, trapped ghosts, Mother Mary being terrifying inside, and monsters lurking outside.  But her survival and ultimate escape comes in no small part from the warmth and love in her own self.  Added interest comes from the identities of all the ghosts (who come from many different times) that Eden meets. Mother Mary's backstory packs an especially intense punch--she isn't just a cardboard villain, but someone who was badly wronged who really does want her "children" to love her.

There's no miraculous end to Eden's grief as a result of her sojourn among the dead, but the story does end back in a place of warmth and light.  It's gorgeously atmospheric and enthralling, so much so it kept my mind firmly its grip, which is especially noteworthy because I read it in a single sitting while my car was failing inspection and The Price is Right blared very loudly over my head.....

My Second Impression of You, by Michelle I. Mason, for Timeslip Tuesay

My Second Impression of You, by Michelle I. Mason (Sept. 20th, Bloomsbury), is a fun YA romance (and even upper Middle Grade readers) fueled by a very interesting time slip plot.

16 year old Maggie is sure that her perfect boyfriend, Theo, is going to ask her to prom when he suggests meeting up at a coffee shop, but instead, he breaks up with her.  Stumbling back to her car, she falls and hurts her foot.  Theo does nothing to help, but his best friend, Carson, who Maggie has never liked, is there and drives her home.

Maggie turns out to have broken a foot bone, and needs surgery, and her life, which centers around drama and dances, crashes down to mingle with the loss of Theo.  She wallows in self-pity.  So when she gets a text offering her the chance to revisit the best day of her life, she can't revisit, and installs the app.  She'll go back to the wonderful, giddy, fairytale day when she and Theo first met.

But this time around, the app keeps intruding, showing her the day from other points of view.  Her best friend has a secret that might ruin the love and trust between them.  Theo is not exactly the romantic hero Maggie had thought.  Carson is more than just Theo's unwelcome wingman.  And so Maggie is forced to think about things that in her self-centered way had never occurred to her....All that she missed the first time around pushes her into being a better, more aware person, and gives her the gift of someone much better than Theo....

The app doesn't deliver it all in one day, so Maggie's real time life keeps getting knocked out of kilter by bits of new information, making her character growth more believable.  She has to work hard to process and act on what she learns, and though the reader might want to shake her (she's isn't very likeable for the first half of the book or so), she does get there in the end.

Michelle Mason is the author of Your Life Has Been Delayed, another fascinating and thought-provoking YA time slip/romance (my review), and I appreciated the interesting twist on time travel she's come with here too.  Maggie was really in the past, and the app had to poke her to keep her from changing things, so it was more than just watching a movie. The app isn't explained at all, and I can't help wonder why Maggie was the chosen one....

It's a really fun premise, well delivered, and the developing romance was sweet.  It was a fast and absorbing read, with the bonus of me wondering what I would do if I were Maggie, and what day I'd want to go back to if I were Maggie....and what I might learn.

This week's round up of middle grade sci fi and fantasy from around the blogs (9/25/22)

The MG SFF round is back again; it was painful to go through my feeds when I got back from vacation to see all the posts I missed in the previous two weeks, but it was a nice and much needed vacation.  Please let me now if I missed your post from this past week!

The Reviews

*Alliana, Girl of Dragons, by Julie Abe. at Mom Read It

Amira and Hamza Series (Books 1 and *2), by Samira Ahmed, at The Bookwyrm's Den

The Battle of the Snake (The Adventures of Crimson and the Guardian #1) by Karen Cossey, at Say What?

*Children of Stardust, by Edudzi Adodo, at Say What?

*Darkroom, by K.R. Alexander, at Ms. Yingling Reads

*Dragon Destiny, by Kevin and Katie Tsang, at Sifa Elizabeth Reads

*Frigg’s Journey to Anasgar (Chronicles of Nadavir #1) by Deb Cushman at Say What?

The Girl and the Ghost, by Hanna Alkaf, at By Singing Light

*The Girl in White, by Linday Currie, at Charlotte's Library

Green Ember series, by S.D. Smith (books 2-4) at Valinora Troy

*Healer and Witch, by Nancy Werlin, at Children's Books Heal

The Little Match Girl Strikes Back, by Emma Carroll & Lauren Child, at Scope for Imagination

Little Women: Mermaid Edition, by Megan Lois Whitehill, at Independent Book Review

*Ravenfall, by Kalyn Josephson, at Ms. Yingling Reads

Relativly Normal Secrets, by C.W. Allen, at Say What?

*Serwa Boateng's Guide to Vampire Hunting, by Roseanne A. Brown,  at  Nerdophiles, The Bookwyrm's Den, and Ms. Yingling Reads

*Shad Hadid and the Alchemists of Alexandria, by George Jreije, at Say What?

*The Sisters of Luna Island,by Stacy Hackney, at Lazy Day Literature

*Tall Tales (Once Upon Another Time, #2) by James Riley, at Bookworm for Kids

A Tangle of Spells (A Pinch of Magic #3) by Michelle Harrison, at Say What? 

*A Taste Of Magic (Park Row Magic Academy #1), by J. Elle, at Charlotte's Library

*The Tiltersmith, by Amy Herrick, at Always in the Middle

The Treekeepers,by Kieran Larwood, at Magic Fiction Since Potter

War of the Wind, by Victoria Williamson, at Book Craic

A Wizard's Guide to Defensive Baking, by T. Kingfisher, at Hidden in Pages

Authors and Interviews

Margi Preus (*Windswept) at The Horn Book

L.T. Getty (The Mermaid and the Unicorns) at Jazzy Book Reviews

Sarah Allen (The Nightmare House) at MG Book Village

Mike DiCerto (A Nick of Time) at Nuttin' But Books

Other Good Stuff

The public nomination period for the Cybils Awards runs Oct 1-15, followed by a week for publishers and authors to fill in gaps.  As always, I want All the Books nominated, and so please start thinking about what books you want to show love for! I've put * next to the books in this round up that are eligible (published in the US or Canada from Oct 16 2021 to October 15 2022); as always, let me know if you see a mistake.  NB -- Elementary/Middle Grade Speculative fiction doesn't take books only available digitally.

A Taste Of Magic (Park Row Magic Academy #1), by J. Elle

This year has been absolutely stellar for magical middle grade school stories; each one I've read has surprised me with its twists of the genre!  And A Taste Of Magic (Park Row Magic Academy #1), by J. Elle (August 30th 2022, Bloomsbury) is no exception--it is a fresh, delightful read!

12-year-old Kyana is pretty happy with her life in her neighborhood of Park Row.  Sure, her mom has to work way to hard because money is tight, and she's under pressure to well at school, even at math...but she has her very dear best friend, Nae, to make school better, and her very dear grandma to love and cook with at home.  Then she discovers she has magic, and she has to spend every Saturday at Park Row Magic Academy, even though the first day of class there is Nae's birthday party....and she can't tell anyone about the magic.

Kyana is determined to excel at magic, especially the Charms part of it, which seems most likely to help her mom out financially.  But even as she gets better at magic, she gets deeper into a web of lies with Nae about where she is on Saturdays, pushing their friendship to the breaking point.  To add to her worries, her grandma's mind is slowly being swallowed by Alzheimer's.  And then the bomb drops--the Park Row magic school is going to be closed due to lack of funding.  The other city magic schools, in whiter and richer neighborhoods, will stay open, and if Kyana can come up with several thousand dollars, she can finish her initial training at one of them.  If she can't (and her mother can't work any harder than she does, so it seems impossible) she'll loose her magic, just as she's finding out what her own special gift is and overcoming her self-doubt.

So wining a city wide baking contest with a sweet cash prize seems to be the obvious answer, and her grandma's recipes, which have a magic of their own, are perfect for it. But when Kyana inadvertently contaminates her first round entry of cupcakes with inadvertent magic, she creates a problem she can't fix alone.  She'll need every friend she has--old, new, and unexpected--and a bit of help from magical (and adorable) cat-like beings to fix things.  And she has to keep on baking, because she's not about to loose hope.

The various very relatable tensions in Kyana's life, with their real world echoes made me anxious at times.  But they are lightened beautifully by the wonder of her entry into a world of magic, by friendship and love, by delightful cooking, and of course magical "kittens."   And I was left feeling  warm and cozy, so excited by the #1 in the title -- I can't wait for more!

A sweet treat of a book!

disclaimer: review copy received from the publisher

The Girl in White, by Lindsay Currie

I am back from vacation--a week and a half in Montana, mostly spent volunteering with the Forest Service fixing up some old buildings at a history tree nursery, and less time visiting used bookstores.  In case anyone is interested, here is my haul (the books whose titles can't be read are Great Day in the Morning, by Florence Crannell Means, and Janine, by Robin McKown).

More books coming home than I took with me (8 ARCs, mostly mg fantasy), and I enjoyed reading them. The result is that I am now behind on reviews....so I hope to review lots in the coming week.

First up is The Girl in White, by Lindsay Currie (September 6th 2022 by Sourcebooks Young Readers), a nice ghost story with which to kick off the spooky season of Fall!

Mallory has been uprooted from Chicago to Eastport, MA--a quaint ocean town. There's a twist to the quaintness, though--the town capitalizes it reputation on being a spooky hotspot. Mallory's parents have plunged into the thick of the spooky stories, opening a restaurant in a building where a casket came tumbling out of a collapsing interior wall. The horror of it is embraced by her parents, and the restaurant is thriving, but Mallory is almost completely fed up with non-stop ghost stories all the time, and totally fed up with the town's fetishization of one legend in particular--that of Sweet Molly, whose brother Liam was lost at sea in the 19th century when the townsfolk forced him to set out on a fishing voyage (for economic reasons) in stormy weather. After he was quickly lost at sea, Molly swore she'd get revenge on the town, and now she's become one of its most popular (aka moneymaking) cursed legends.

The anniversary of Liam's death is approaching, the town is planning one of its biggest ever Sweet Molly extravagances, and Mallory, to her horror, is being haunted by Molly's ghost.  It stinks to be Mallory, sleep deprived, even less in control of her life than being uprooted, to the point where she literally is in danger (the ghost makes her sleep walk) and forced to endure all the Sweet Molly madness of the town.

Mallory can't explain away her terrifying encounters with Molly, and she has no idea how to get them to stop. Fortunately, she has good friends, one of them a earlier victim of Molly's harassment, and in a race against time, as strange and terrifying weather hits Eastport, and the climax of the festival approaches, they work together to find the true story of Molly and Liam....

The mix of very creepy ghost, local history gone out of control, and real world complexities of loyalty to family and friends make this one I'm sure will please its target audience lots! It's all woven together very well, with both the spookiness of Sweet Molly strong enough to satisfy young horror readers, and the new kid in town story satisfying those who aren't reading it for the scares.

As a grown-up reader, I appreciated that Mallory and her parents and friends were able to work through the wrinkles in their relationships with good faith and little drama. I respected the horror element of the plot; it was very vividly described in good mg horror fashion. That being said, I wondered, as I often do, why ghosts have to be so gosh darn mean when communicating with the living. If you are a ghost who can write messages in blood red paint etc. why not just be explicit? But I guess Molly's one weapon in her quest to change the narrative was her ability to terrorize....peaceful protest wasn't an option, which is an interesting thing to think about.

Which leads to what, to me, an even more interesting aspect of the book--at the heart of the plot is the need to question established narratives, and to revise accepted history. And even though this particular revision is not actually all that weighty, it does matter to Molly, and to the town. It's the sort of book that might well put thoughts into kids' heads that will lead them to become good critical thinkers as they get older, which is a good thing!

disclaimer: review copy received from the publisher